The new administration is encouraging state experiments in lean and punitive social policy.
By Colin Gordon, Dissent
It is unclear how the full policy agenda of the new presidential administration—combining both petty vindictiveness and the conservative fever dreams of Project 2025—will unfold. But three weeks of nakedly authoritarian executive orders, broadsides against the civil service, and Elon Musk and his minions ransacking federal agencies and their payment systems is less than encouraging. Congressional budget hawks, meanwhile, are promising permanent tax cuts and deep programmatic and budget cuts to pay for them.
At the state level, activists and progressive legislators will try to sustain progress made in the last four years and protect us from the worst of Trump 2.0, especially on labor, environmental, and immigration policy. At the same time, red state governors and legislators are parroting Trump’s every move, promising to slash spending, and looking to tear down federal standards or guardrails that get in their way.
Consider social policy. In some respects, there is not much more damage that a second Trump administration can do. By design and by neglect, federal policy has already ceded program eligibility and benefit determinations to states and local control. Some social assistance programs still show their Jim Crow roots, with their reach and generosity stunted by deference to state and local labor markets. That fragmentation was an effect of the “end of welfare as we know it” in 1996.
As a result, rates and levels of coverage are dismal: Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) reaches just 13 percent of poor families in the median state, with an annual benefit of just over $5,000; unemployment insurance (UI) reaches just one in three of unemployed people at the median, with an annual benefit just under $5,000. No less troubling is the yawning variation across the states: in the bottom five, only 4 percent of poor families receive TANF, with an annual stipend of only $2,400, while one in five unemployed workers collects UI, at an annual benefit of barely $3,000.
Recent Posts
‘Unconstitutional. Unethical. Authoritarian.’ ICE Bars Millions Of Immigrants From Bond Hearings
Take Action Now One watchdog said the new policy “seems like a blatant attempt to stop them from exercising their right to due process.”……
Americans Are Not Nearly Alarmed Enough About Climate Change
Take Action Now Americans still don’t comprehend how imminent, dangerous, and far-reaching the threat is—and journalists are partly to blame.By…
The IRS Is Building A Vast System To Share Millions Of Taxpayers’ Data With ICE
Take Action Now ProPublica has obtained the blueprint for the Trump administration’s unprecedented plan to turn over IRS records to Homeland Security…
Israel’s Sudden Assault On Syria Is Unchecked Aggression
Take Action Now Jerusalem is bombing Damascus and threatening al-Sharaa’s rule, while Washington was hoping to help the nascent government on…