The war offers a chance to re-imagine US foreign policy. But first, stopping the rehabilitation of liberal interventionism is key.
by Michael Brenes, Responsible Statecraft
Writing in The Atlantic late last month, journalist George Parker posited a “new theory of American power,” a liberal internationalism that accounted for a “recognition of limits” for US foreign policy. Packer summed up this strategy toward the end of his essay: “Align US policy with the universal desire for freedom, but maintain a keen sense of unintended consequences and no illusions of easy success.”
This was both a challenge and a promise to Americans wanting to move on from the War on Terror: don’t forget the War on Terror’s failures—and reject its methods (torture and rendition)—but maintain a vision of global “freedom” flourishing through military power. The war in Ukraine, Packer argued, had killed the (now fleeting) popularity of “restraint”—the idea that the United States should scale back its international commitments, cut or remake the military budget to reflect a reduced role for the US in the world, and give up on a strategy of what political scientist Barry Posen has called “liberal hegemony.”

As one would imagine, Packer’s essay caused a stir, if not a visceral loathing, among restrainers. But as historian Samuel Moyn tweeted, Packer’s essay—while gilding liberal internationalism for a rehabilitation of American primacy—reflected the reality that the old order cannot return after the War on Terror, “that a militarism-first option of liberal warmongers can’t simply be revived.”
Recent Posts
Call It Genocide, Pay The Price
December 1, 2023
Take Action Now Private colleges and employers can, and do, ignore the right to speak freely. By Bill Lueders, The Progressive A common…
U.S. Says If CIA-Backed Embassy Security Opened Phones Of Assange Visitors, It Was Constitutional
December 1, 2023
Take Action Now “There are several cases,” U.S. Attorney Jean-David Barnea argued, “that say that by giving your phone to someone else, you have…
Mehdi Hasan Is Fired From MSNBC After Reports Critical Of Israel
December 1, 2023
Take Action Now “Mehdi Hasan’s program has felt like an oasis on air and more needed than ever,” said one Palestinian American…
Israel’s Calculated Bombing Of Gaza Reveals Mass Murder Intent
December 1, 2023
Take Action Now Permissive airstrikes on non-military targets and the use of an artificial intelligence system have enabled the Israeli army to…