Nuclear secrecy does not equal nuclear security, says analyst Matt Korda
by Matt Korda, Outrider
No one wants to see new countries develop nuclear weapons or see non-state actors get their hands on the bomb. To that end, certain information about nuclear weapons––in particular, details about how to build or access them––should remain classified.
But not all information about countries’ nuclear weapons should be kept secret. And in recent years, nuclear-armed states have increasingly––and unnecessarily––withheld critical details about their nuclear arsenals from their publics, allies, and adversaries.
Ambiguity about nuclear stockpiles, deployments, and employment policies can lead to worst-case assumptions about how countries will develop or use nuclear weapons in the future––thus exacerbating the arms race and increasing the possibility of miscalculation, particularly during times of heightened nuclear tensions.
In contrast, Jon Wolfsthal––former National Security Council Senior Director for Arms Control and Nonproliferation during the Obama administration––suggests that nuclear transparency can actually bolster U.S. deterrence objectives.
“The idea that declassifying the total number of weapons we have, or deploy, or that our operation will somehow make it easier for adversaries or competitors to compete with or defeat us is nonsensical,” says Wolfsthal. “Either we have a reliable, survivable retaliatory force (which we do), or we don’t. If we do, we should be clear and assertive about it, to show that we are both confident in our forces and that our allies should be confident in them too.”
Recent Posts
Students On The Front Line For A Free Palestine
April 26, 2024
Take Action Now The Gaza protests are moral, brave, and part of a much broader struggle. by Richard (RJ) Eskow, The Zero Hour Report It’s…
Nuclear Power’s Lethal, Larcenous End Game
April 26, 2024
Take Action Now For the first time since 1954, no large new atomic reactors are under construction or on order in the United States. By Harvey…
200 Caring People Are Ready To Sail On The Freedom Flotilla To Gaza
April 25, 2024
Take Action Now For decades, corporations have used taxpayer-funded fellowship opportunities to help them secure billion-dollar defense contracts.…
Is The Iran Nuclear Deal Dead Forever?
April 25, 2024
Take Action Now Trump blew up the deal — why hasn’t Biden taken the opportunity to fix it? by Bob Dreyfuss, Tom Dispatch One, erratic and…