The discussion revolves around the moral and political implications of Israel’s actions in Gaza, the historical context of Zionism, and the need for a reevaluation of Jewish identity and solidarity in light of the ongoing conflict.
By RJ Eskow and Peter Beinart, The Zero Hour
In a conversation with Richard Eskow, Peter Beinart discusses his book, Being Jewish After the Destruction of Gaza: A Reckoning, which calls for a moral reevaluation of Jewish identity and solidarity in light of Israel’s actions in Gaza.
The discussion revolves around the moral and political implications of Israel’s actions in Gaza, the historical context of Zionism, and the need for a reevaluation of Jewish identity and solidarity in light of the ongoing conflict. Beinart argues that the destruction of Gaza, carried out with American support and in the name of the Jewish people, demands a moral reckoning. He emphasizes the catastrophic humanitarian impact on Palestinians and the complicity of many Jewish institutions.

Beinart critiques the ethical foundations of Zionism, arguing that Jewish safety and justice depend on equality under the law rather than ethno-nationalist supremacy. He reflects on the historical displacement of Palestinians, the failure of nonviolent resistance due to lack of support, and the emotional challenges of confronting deeply held beliefs about Israel. He challenges the notion that Jewish safety depends on maintaining a Jewish state with legal supremacy. He argues that equality under the law, rather than ethno-nationalism, is the key to long-term safety for both Jews and Palestinians.
While expressing pessimism about the current trajectory, Beinart hopes for a global movement that pressures Israel to recognize Palestinian rights and move toward a future of mutual equality and coexistence. The conversation underscores the need for a profound moral and political reckoning, advocating for a future based on equality and mutual recognition rather than domination and exclusion.
Recent Posts
House Bill Would Let Marco Rubio Strip Passports Over Political Speech
September 15, 2025
Take Action Now Provision would let the Secretary of State deny or revoke passports over alleged “material support” as critics warn of thought…
Targeting Venezuela, Trump Escalates U.S. Campaign Of Aggression In Latin America
September 15, 2025
Take Action Now The US and Latin American right have long mobilized to remove challenges to their traditional privileges and control.By Jonathan…
GOP-Led Congressional Committee Votes To Block Trump From Rescheduling Marijuana
September 14, 2025
Take Action Now Can the Trump administration, or any administration, declare people guilty and treat them as criminals, absent the transparent legal…
Never Forget What?
September 13, 2025
Take Action Now Never forget meant never forgive. Never forget meant someone would pay. And with my Muslim name, my South Asian heritage, I knew who…