The war is providing military hawks with all the fodder they need to argue for more of an overseas military presence.
By Stephen M. Walt, Responsible Statecraft
Every few months some card-carrying member of the foreign policy establishment takes up his or her pen to explain why the slightest reduction in America’s far-flung overseas commitments would have catastrophic consequences for the Republic.
This week, that task fell to Hal Brands, an old hand at this game, who took to the pages of the Washington Post and Bloomberg News to offer up another ill-aimed attack at the so-called “restraint coalition.”
Brand’s argument is straightforward. Until the war in Ukraine, a broad coalition of isolationists, nationalists, realists, and other dissidents was “ascendant.” According to him, this group wants to drastically reduce America’s current level of global engagement. But Russia’s invasion has reminded us of what can happen if the United States withdraws, and other great powers get to run the world. In his words, it has “illuminated the virtues of American power.” The unstated but unmistakable implication: don’t pay any attention to those foolish restrainers, whose brief moment of prominence is thankfully coming to an end.

The first problem lies in Brands’ characterization of the “restraint coalition.” He acknowledges that it is a “broad church” whose members disagree on many issues. But lumping them all together allows him to portray it as a large and potentially dangerous movement, while sparing him the trouble of addressing their specific policy recommendations. And the differences really aren’t that important, because for Brands, they’re all part of the same team.
Recent Posts
In Ukraine, Biden Is Walking Into A Trap
March 20, 2023
Take Action Now Three key factors show why the administration needs to press the accelerator pedal on negotiations with Russia now. by…
Immediate Action Is Needed To Ensure ‘A Livable Future For All,’ UN Climate Panel Says
March 20, 2023
Take Action Now World needs a “quantum leap” in climate ambition to stave off devastating consequences. By Joseph Winters, Grist Current and future…
The Lords of Chaos
March 20, 2023
Take Action Now The politicians and shills in the media who orchestrated 20 years of military debacles in the Middle East, and who seek a world…
War Made Easy: The Iraq War 20 Years Later
March 19, 2023
Take Action Now This critically acclaimed documentary exhumes five decades of remarkable archival footage to show how presidents from both parties…