Lumping US adversaries into a single-headed monster is a paranoid delusion used as to fuel militarism.
by Daniel Larison, Responsible Statecraft
The head of Indo-Pacific Command, Admiral John Aquilino, recently warned members of the House Armed Services Committee about increasing cooperation among Russia, China, Iran, and North Korea and said, “We’re almost back to the axis of evil.”
There has been something of a revival of this discredited Bush-era idea in recent years, and it has become more common for members of Congress and now high-ranking military officers to describe the relationships between various authoritarian states using some version of George W. Bush’s ridiculous phrase.

While it is true that there has been some increased cooperation between these four governments, it is dangerous and misleading to suggest that they form anything resembling a close alliance or coalition. If the U.S. were to “act accordingly,” as Adm. Aquilino recommended, it would risk driving these states much closer together and creating the very axis that U.S. officials fear.
Aquilino’s phrasing is revealing. When he said, “we’re almost back to the axis of evil,” that seems to suggest that he thinks there was a real one that serves as a model for the current group. The first “axis of evil” that George W. Bush denounced in his 2002 State of the Union address was made up of three states — Iran, Iraq, and North Korea — that were united only by Washington’s hostility to them. Iran and Iraq had long been enemies and remained so at the time, and North Korea was added to the mix so that it wouldn’t be entirely fixated on predominantly Muslim countries. These states weren’t working together, and two of them were opposed to each other.
Recent Posts
The Trump-Mamdani Show Was Amazing. But Downsides For Progressives Could Turn Out To Be Steep
November 25, 2025
Take Action Now It’s all well and good to laud Mamdani’s extraordinary political talents and inspiring leadership for social justice. At the same…
ICE Sent 600 Immigrant Kids To Detention In Federal Shelters This Year. It’s A New Record.
November 24, 2025
Take Action Now This year ICE has sent more immigrant children into the federal shelter system than in the previous four years combined. New data…
The Return Of Nuclear Proliferation
November 24, 2025
Take Action Now A recent article in the establishment security journal Foreign Affairs makes the case for nuclear proliferation among America’s…
Are Zohran Mamdani and Katie Wilson Democratic Socialists or FDR Democrats? They Are Both
November 23, 2025
Take Action Now This is fitting: For more than a century, socialism has been integral to American progressivism, championing early many of the…




