By Khury Petersen-Smith, YES Magazine
When U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar decried Israel’s 11-day aerial bombardment of Gaza this May and declared that “Palestinians deserve protection,” Florida’s Republican U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio responded by saying that Israeli violence and U.S. support for it were justified because Israelis “live in a very tough neighborhood.”
Rubio did not invent that phrase or its use in describing Israel’s place in the region where it sits. In 2016, 82 hawkish senators signed onto a letter to President Barack Obama advocating greater guarantees of military aid to Israel, saying that “members of Congress from both parties have been proud to work with you and previous administrations to provide Israel the essential resources it needs to survive in a very tough neighborhood.”
Conservative think tank analysts also use the term, such as Aaron David Miller of the Carnegie Endowment for Peace—who calls Israel “a tiny state in a tough neighborhood”—as do critics of U.S. policy toward Israel. For example, Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg has used the phrase, “a challenging neighborhood” and progressive U.S. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) has said, “I think Israel is in a really tough neighborhood.”
Recent Posts
62 percent Of Democrats Agree Party Leadership Should Be Replaced: Survey
June 20, 2025
Take Action Now The party has found it difficult to build a cohesive message as the Democratic National Committee (DNC) has been embroiled in…
Democratic Leadership Is Complacent In The Face Of Iran War Threat
June 20, 2025
Take Action Now “It’s embarrassing that some problematic far-right figures are speaking out more forcefully against direct military…
The Revolution Will Not Be Digitized: A “No Kings” Debrief
June 19, 2025
Take Action Now What worked, what didn’t—and what about Gaza?By RJ Eskow, The Zero Hour Report The “after-action review” is an exercise that the…
AIPAC Is Cajoling Congress Into Supporting War With Iran
June 19, 2025
Take Action Now The pro-Israel lobbying group has sent a flurry of communications to members of Congress, citing specific language for them to parrot…