Trump's New Cuba Policy Is Bad For The U.S. And Cuba

Trump’s new Cuba policy will be bad for migrants and the U.S.

On his return to the presidency on January 20, Donald Trump rescinded his predecessor Joe Biden’s short-lived removal of Cuba from the State Sponsor of Terrorism (SSOT) designation. The SSOT designation will further isolate Cuba diplomatically and economically.

Biden only removed Cuba on January 14. Cuba was originally designated as SSOT in 1982. As the U.S. State Department explains, “Cuba was designated as a State Sponsor of Terrorism in 1982 because of its long history of providing advice, safe haven, communications, training, and financial support to guerrilla groups and individual terrorists.” Perhaps it would be more accurate to say that Fidel Castro and the Cuban government offered support to young revolutionaries fighting against reactionary governments, civilian dictators, and military juntas—so long as those groups reciprocated by adhering to Cuba’s political line.

The Cuban Revolution of 1959 had inspired revolutionary guerrilla groups throughout Latin America, and the Argentine-Cuban revolutionary Ernesto Che Guevara and the Cuban government of Fidel Castro encouraged and supported them. French intellectual Regis Debray popularized the concept of guerrilla warfare in Europe and beyond. Within a decade, however, the guerrilla movements had been crushed by military coups in Chile (1973), Uruguay (1973), and Argentina (1976), and in the 1970s in the Central American nations of El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras dictators and military juntas defeated the guerrillas there. Only Nicaragua’s Sandinistas were victorious, and only for a few years. Idealism and heroism were not enough to win. The guerrilla organizations generally had no base among the working class or the peasantry and their violent tactics often alienated the rest of society. Debray himself criticized the guerrilla warfare idea and listed its faults in his later book Critique of Arms. The moment passed and in the 1990s, Cuba stopped supporting guerrilla groups and hasn’t done so now for over 30 years. In any case these guerrilla organizations weren’t terrorists if terrorism means the use of political violence against non-combatant bystanders either deliberately or as a result of gross negligence. In general, they fought oppressive states and their military and police.

Large Cuban flag hanging vertically on a facade of colonial building Inglaterra Hotel in the historical center of Old Havana.

There was another issue, however, a big one. The U.S. government’s opposition to Cuba from the early 1960s to the 1990s was also once motivated by Cuba’s alliance with the Soviet Union and the Communist Eastern Bloc. In May of 1962, Russian Premier Nikita Khrushchev and Cuban leader Castro agreed to placing nuclear missiles in Cuba, leading to the Cuban missile crisis. While the missiles were withdrawn, Cuban and Soviet ties grew stronger. By the 1970s Cuba had been completely structurally and politically assimilated to the Soviet Union, a totalitarian one-party state controlled everything and secret police who rotted out opponents. Cuba supported the repression of the Czechoslovak Prague Spring, a movement for democratic socialism, in 1968. And it also backed the Polish Communist government’s crackdown on the Solidarity union movement of 1980 that was also fighting for democracy. The United States supported all sorts of other dictatorships in Latin America and elsewhere, but Cuba’s alliance with the Soviet Union justified a variety of embargos, trade restrictions, and other measures, including attempted assassinations of Castro. But of course, the Soviet Union fell in 1991, and the Communist Bloc disintegrated and are not an issue today.

The U.S. government also keeps Cuba on the SSOT list because of Cuba’s “subversion of U.S. justice.” This refers to Cuba having given sanctuary to a number of Black radicals of the 1960s and 70s, some of them Black Panthers, who were involved in violent incidents that included murder, among them Assata Shakur, Ismael La Beet, and Charles Lee Hill, all now in their late 70s and 80s. Some felt they could not get a fair trial in the United States. The U.S. suspects or criminals being harbored in Cuba include some CIA agents who defected. Cuba no longer has political relationships to groups like the Panthers, and these individuals no longer pose any threat to the United States. Certainly, Cuba’s having offered them refuge 30 or 40 years ago has nothing to do with supporting terrorism then and there is no such issue today.