Has the American myth of the Good War helped ensnare us in bad ones?
By Carlos Lozada, The New Yorker
The terrorist strikes of September 11, 2001, supposedly launched a new kind of American war, with unfamiliar foes, unlikely alliances, and unthinkable tactics. But the language deployed to interpret this conflict was decidedly old-school, the comfort food of martial rhetoric. With the Axis of Evil, the menace of Fascism (remixed as “Islamofascism”), and the Pearl Harbor references, the Second World War hovered over what would become known as the global war on terror, infusing it with righteousness.
This latest war, President George W. Bush said, would have a scope and a stature evoking the American response to that other attack on the U.S. “one Sunday in 1941.” It wouldn’t be like Desert Storm, a conflict tightly bounded in time and space; instead, it was a call to global engagement and even to national greatness. “This generation will lift the dark threat of violence from our people and our future,” Bush avowed.

Elizabeth D. Samet finds such familiarity endlessly familiar. “Every American exercise of military force since World War II, at least in the eyes of its architects, has inherited that war’s moral justification and been understood as its offspring: motivated by its memory, prosecuted in its shadow, inevitably measured against it,” she writes in “Looking for the Good War: American Amnesia and the Violent Pursuit of Happiness” (Farrar, Straus & Giroux).
Recent Posts
An Obscure Military Program Helps Local Cops Buy Armored Cars And Spyware. It Might Balloon Under Trump.
October 30, 2025
Take Action Now The 1122 program, as it’s known, presents a danger to protesters facing off against militarized cops, according to a new report.By…
‘Extremely Dangerous For Humanity’: Trump Orders Resumption Of U.S. Nuclear Weapons Testing
October 30, 2025
Take Action Now “By foolishly announcing his intention resume nuclear testing,” said one expert, “Trump will trigger strong public opposition in…
The Stunning Hypocrisy Of U.S. Foreign Policy
October 29, 2025
Take Action Now The US government regards the entire world as its legitimate sphere of influence, including the backyards of its rivals.By Donald…
The Lost Language Of The Working Class: Reviving Economic Populism In The Democratic Party
October 29, 2025
Take Action Now A detailed account of the Democrats’ alienation from working America and how candidates like Dan Osborn and Zohran Mamdani point the…




