Destitution should not be a tool of U.S. foreign policy.
By Jacob Batinga, Current Affairs
What right does the United States have to starve civilians to achieve political goals? Despite its obvious importance, this question is largely absent from mainstream discourse. Through economic sanctions, or economic warfare, the U.S. can unilaterally collapse economies and generate famine in foreign countries. The civilian death toll from sanctions is often equal to—and sometimes greater than—the toll from conventional warfare. Yet on both sides of the aisle, it is taken for granted that we have the “right” to impose destitution on civilian populations in order to advance our interests.
The U.S. administers two types of sanctions: primary and secondary sanctions. Primary sanctions cut off economic relations between targeted foreign entities—states, individuals, industries, or corporations—and the American economy. Secondary sanctions, also known as “extraterritorial sanctions,” are more pernicious. Secondary sanctions impose sanctions or other penalties on third parties not under the jurisdiction of the U.S. if they refuse to cease economic relations with the entity under primary sanctions. For example, the U.S. imposed both primary and secondary sanctions on the Central Bank of Iran (CBI). Therefore, the U.S. prohibits American citizens and corporations from conducting business with the bank (primary sanctions), and imposes sanctions on any foreign state, individual, or corporation that chooses to work with the CBI (secondary sanctions).
Many legal scholars and most of the world, including the European Union, maintain that these secondary sanctions clearly violate well established principles of international law, interfere with the sovereignty of foreign governments, and are ultimately illegitimate.
Recent Posts
The Trump-Mamdani Show Was Amazing. But Downsides For Progressives Could Turn Out To Be Steep
Take Action Now It’s all well and good to laud Mamdani’s extraordinary political talents and inspiring leadership for social justice. At the same…
ICE Sent 600 Immigrant Kids To Detention In Federal Shelters This Year. It’s A New Record.
Take Action Now This year ICE has sent more immigrant children into the federal shelter system than in the previous four years combined. New data…
The Return Of Nuclear Proliferation
Take Action Now A recent article in the establishment security journal Foreign Affairs makes the case for nuclear proliferation among America’s…
Are Zohran Mamdani and Katie Wilson Democratic Socialists or FDR Democrats? They Are Both
Take Action Now This is fitting: For more than a century, socialism has been integral to American progressivism, championing early many of the…