Think tank’s $75,000 review is a new round in the ICBM fight as top House defense Republicans call contract a waste of money.
By Anthony Capaccio, Bloomberg
A tiny Pentagon contract for an influential Washington think tank to study the nation’s nuclear arsenal is sparking outsized congressional scrutiny, in a prelude to a bigger fight over whether to spend billions of dollars buying new intercontinental ballistic missiles.
The $75,000 contract awarded in December to the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace will result in a five- to seven-page unclassified paper later this month examining “the relative risks and benefits of various options regarding the land-based leg of the U.S. nuclear triad.”

Citing previous studies and bipartisan congressional support for new ICBMs, the top Republicans on the House and Senate Armed Services committees — Representative Mike Rogers of Alabama and Senator James Inhofe of Oklahoma– backed language in the $768.2 billion defense policy bill that President Joe Biden signed last month demanding documents on any contract studying whether to extend the service of aging Minuteman III missiles first deployed in 1970 or on “the future of the intercontinental ballistic missile force.”
“There’s no way yet another review can possibly provide any insights that would outweigh a decade’s worth of previous analyses,” Inhofe said in a statement. “It’s puzzling why the administration has insisted on pursuing yet another review of the same thing.” Both lawmakers called it a waste of money.
The tiff reflects a divide over the role of nuclear weapons in U.S. defense policy — and in defense budgeting — and it foreshadows a major political battle this year after the Pentagon releases a new Nuclear Posture Review.
Recent Posts
Should We Invade Israel in the Name of Humanitarianism?
August 2, 2025
Take Action Now For decades, liberal humanitarianism argued that the international community should take military action against states engaged in…
Student Loan Payments To ICE Agents: Unpacking Trump’s “Big, Disastrous Bill”
August 1, 2025
Take Action Now Two activists arrested in the fight against Trump’s landmark legislation discuss the bill’s consequences, from student debt to…
Kamala Harris Should Not Run For President In 2028
August 1, 2025
Take Action Now A Harris 2028 campaign would remind Democratic voters of her undue loyalty to Biden, whose brand is now badly tarnished in his own…
Columbia University’s Capitulation To Trump Endangers Students
August 1, 2025
Take Action Now As Columbia pursues a second investigation into a May library protest, the university adopts a sweeping definition of antisemitism…