“Representing Guantánamo detainees was entirely about the limits of executive power, not exoneration of terrorists. It’s work she should be applauded for, unless you’re, you know, anti-democracy.”
By Brett Wilkins, Common Dreams
U.S. Supreme Court nominee Ketanji Brown Jackson on Tuesday deflected attacks from Republican senators who questioned her work as a defense attorney for Guantánamo Bay detainees, as well as a false allegation that she called former Bush administration officials “war criminals.”
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) implied that Jackson’s assigned work defending detainees held indefinitely without charge or trial in the U.S. military prison at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba imperiled U.S. national security, telling her that “if you tried to do this in World War II, they’d run you out of town.”
Author and journalist Sonali Kolhatkar told Common Dreams that “it’s horrific to see Sen. Graham create twisted knots of logic to justify indefinite detention without due process.”

Kolhatkar accused Graham and other Republican senators of “trying to punish Jackson as a sort of payback to Democrats” for their questioning of Supreme Court Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett—who were appointed by former President Donald Trump—during their confirmation hearings.
“Graham was also childishly petulant that his favorite nominee hadn’t been picked and it was cringeworthy to watch him demand that Jackson respond to what other people had said about a completely different potential pick, Michelle Childs, as if it had any bearing on Jackson’s qualifications,” she added. “The GOP is intent on subjecting her to abuse just to whip up political points.”
For Lindsey Graham to suggest Ketanji Brown Jackson might make this country less secure is hilariously ironic, given Graham's support for both the invasion of Iraq and the Guantanamo Bay gulag is what massively heightened the terrorist threat to the United States.
— Mehdi Hasan (@mehdirhasan) March 22, 2022
Noting Jackson made clear that “representing Guantánamo detainees was entirely about the limits of executive power, not exoneration of terrorists,” Zack Ford of Alliance for Justice tweeted that “it’s work she should be applauded for, unless you’re, you know, anti-democracy.”
During his allotted time for questioning, Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) wondered “why in the world” Jackson—who he called “gracious and charming”—would call former U.S. Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld and former President George W. Bush “war criminals.”
“I don’t remember that particular reference,” Jackson replied. “I did not intend to disparage the president or the secretary of defense.”
MSNBC‘s Mehdi Hasan wrote: “I get it. She has to say that. But let’s be clear: No one should ever have to apologize for disparaging Bush or Rumsfeld.”
She can't say it, but here are the facts:
1. The US government under George W. Bush established a torture program, to torture prisoners.
2. Torture is a war crime.
3. Her brief said her client was tortured, which is a war crime.
Not that complicated. https://t.co/9SaAhqxx83
— Paul Waldman (@paulwaldman1) March 22, 2022
As Senate Judiciary Committee Chair Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) subsequently noted, Jackson never called Rumsfeld or Bush war criminals. What she actually did was file a habeas corpus petition on behalf of individuals subjected to torture—a war crime—during the Bush administration.
“For the record,” tweeted progressive Ohio congressional candidate Nina Turner, “Donald Rumsfeld is a war criminal.”
In the wake of the September 11, 2001 attacks on the United States, Bush administration lawyers drafted memos in an attempt to legalize the torture—officially called “enhanced interrogation”—that was occurring at Guantánamo and at CIA “black sites,” U.S. military prisons, and elsewhere. Rumsfeld approved the torture techniques.
Recent Posts
(Not Quite) Tinder For New Activists: “Why Don’t We Already Have This?”
May 20, 2025
Take Action Now Many people are looking for a way to do something. They have heard that we the people — all of us — may be the last functioning…
What Could The Pentagon’s Record $1 Trillion Budget Pay For Instead?
May 20, 2025
Take Action Now President Trump is seeking a record $1 trillion budget for the Pentagon in 2026. What else could we do with that much money?By…
Trump Is Building A Global Gulag For Immigrants Captured By ICE
May 19, 2025
Take Action Now The U.S. is in talks with 19 nations, including Libya, Kosovo, Rwanda, and Moldova, to accept deportees from other countries.……
How To Fight Trump Without Caving To Corporatists
May 19, 2025
Take Action Now In this interview, Richard Eskow and Norman Solomon discuss how to combat Trumpism without turning to corporatists for their…