The gonzo ethics of seeking to make gobs of money so you can give it away.
by Robert Reich
Today is Giving Tuesday — a day to focus on personal charitable giving to worthy causes.
But what I really want to talk about today is something quite different from charitable giving, although often confused with it: It’s called “effective altruism.” Known as EA to its practitioners, effective altruism urges people to give away a large share of their incomes.
Fine as far as it goes. But EA has been going much further.
One of EA’s most influential proponents is the Oxford philosopher William MacAskill, who has urged young people to seek high-paying jobs in finance (or wherever else they can make gobs of money) on ethical grounds, because they can then donate a large portion of their earnings to worthy causes. For example, by becoming a hedge-fund mogul, MacAskill says, you can donate large sums — and create far more good — than you can as a social worker.

Or to take a different example, MacAskill argues that a young person concerned about the world’s poor could become a doctor in a poor country and possibly save the equivalent of 140 lives in their medical career. But if they took a job that paid them hundreds of millions of dollars, and then donated a big portion of it intelligently, they could save ten times as many lives.
Sounds logical. But wait.
MacAskill’s utilitarian logic leaves out the social costs associated with how a talented young person might make gobs of money in the first place. (One red flag: Elon Musk claims that MacAskill’s giving philosophy is similar to his own.)
Recent Posts
Sen. Bernie Sanders Opposes Unconditional Military Aid To Israel In Funding Bill
December 5, 2023
Take Action Now An additional $10.1 billion in “unconditional military aid” to Israel would be “irresponsible,” the senator…
COP28 Has More Fossil Fuel Lobbyists In Attendance Than Ever
December 5, 2023
Take Action Now There are 2,456 fossil fuel interests at this year’s U.N. climate summit, nearly four times more than any past year, according…
“The Madness Of Militarism,” The 2023 Ellsberg Lecture By Norman Solomon
December 5, 2023
Take Action Now Norman Solomon reflects on ‘the madness of militarism’ in the Ellsberg Lecture By Norman Solomon, Nation of Change In…
The U.S. Has Given Israel An Endless Supply Of Smart Bombs
December 5, 2023
Take Action Now Nearly three years ago, Congress gave Israel a pass to stockpile precision-guided bombs “without regard to annual limits.” An inside…