Abolitionists have made great progress and the death penalty is in retreat. For capital punishment advocates, desperate measures have been required to keep the machinery of death running.
By Austin Sarat, Slate
Now more than ever there are two distinct worlds of capital punishment in the United States. It has long been the case that the death penalty has flourished in some regions of the country and in some states more than in others. And the release of the Death Penalty Information Center’s (DPIC) annual report for 2021 makes clear that the distance between those two divergent paths rapidly increased last year.

“The death penalty in 2021 was defined by two competing forces: the continuing long-term erosion of capital punishment across most of the country, and extreme conduct by a dwindling number of outlier jurisdictions to continue to pursue death sentences and executions,” The DPIC report noted. Capital punishment increasingly is used in just a few idiosyncratic locales and offers another fault line in this country’s fragmented political, legal, and cultural life.
As in many other areas of American life, supporters and opponents of the death penalty regard each other as enemies, not just as opponents. They see the world in fundamentally different ways and think of the political struggle over the death penalty as a struggle over fundamental values and different ways of life.
As Emory University historian Daniel LaChance explains, “These days, support for capital punishment is concentrated among whites, Protestants, and Republicans—key demographic constituencies of the conservative side of the late twentieth century culture wars…. Support for the death penalty is not only a tool for controlling crime, but also an expression of allegiance to values—personal responsibility, the sacredness of innocent life, and the firmness of a nation’s convictions—that they feel have degraded in the United States since the 1960s.”
Progressives, in contrast, see America’s continuing use of capital punishment as unjust, barbaric, and a sign of moral backwardness.
As a result, we can expect death penalty politics to grow more, not less, bitter and more intense, as the two worlds of capital punishment come to terms with new realities.
What are these new realities?
Recent Posts
Zohran Mamdani Is Breaking Through
April 29, 2025
Take Action Now The 33-year-old socialist Zohran Mamdani’s laser focus on affordability, smart media strategy, and undeniable charisma have made him…
Can Unionizing Grocery Workers Defeat Supermarket Giants?
April 29, 2025
Take Action Now Kroger and Albertsons tried to merge; union organizing stopped them. But the fight for grocery workers is just beginning.By Sarah…
Is The Democratic Party Starting To Show Cracks?
April 29, 2025
Take Action Now For years, we were told the Democratic Party was fine. Now even a few party elders are admitting it’s broken. But naming the problem…
Inspector General Probes Whether Trump, DOGE Sought Private Taxpayer Information
April 28, 2025
Take Action Now The request, spelled out in an email obtained by ProPublica, comes amid concerns that DOGE has overstepped its bounds in seeking…