It’s not enough for Washington to urge talks from behind the scenes, while insisting in public that only Kyiv can negotiate.
by Anatol Lieven, Responsible Statecraft
It is now clear that the Ukrainian offensive of the summer and fall of 2023 has failed, with minimal gains and enormous losses. There has been no repeat of the sweeping Ukrainian victories of 2022. Ukrainian army chief General Valery Zaluzhny has admitted that the war has now entered a stalemate.
Russia is now attacking in its turn; and although so far its forces also have made only very slow progress, time does not appear to be on Ukraine’s side. Russia has some four times Ukraine’s population and 14 times its GDP, which give it huge advantages in what has become a war of attrition. Serious imbalances in the U.S. and European military industries mean that Russia is also producing far more shells than Ukraine is receiving from the West.
Ukraine’s victories in the first months of the war were due to the courage and grit of Ukrainian soldiers, certain particularly effective Western weapons, and extremely bad Russian planning. They were also, however, attributable to the fact that Ukraine was able to mobilize more men than Russia, due to President Putin’s hesitation over increasing conscription. That advantage has now been reversed.
Moreover, as recent developments in the U.S. Congress and in Europe make clear, there can be no guarantee that Western aid will continue at levels sufficient to allow Ukraine to continue the fight successfully.
Recent Posts
Students Confront UVa President Jim Ryan, Demand Answers After Police Crackdown On Protesters
May 10, 2024
Take Action Now Ryan walked into the room Thursday expecting a meeting with a student organization. That’s not what he found. By Jason…
IRS Now Targeting People Who Threaten Washington’s “Ability To Govern”
May 10, 2024
Take Action Now The tax agency could now target protesters, broad new guidelines suggest By Ken Klippenstein, KenKlippenstein.com The Internal…
War Culture Hates The Ethical Passion Of The Young
May 9, 2024
Take Action Now In the Thrall of a Dominant Death Culture By Norman Solomon, Tom Dispatch Persisting in his support for an unpopular war, the…
Killing The Iran Nuclear Deal Was One Of Trump’s Biggest Failures
May 9, 2024
Take Action Now Six years after the US withdrew from the JCPOA, prospects for its resurrection are dim and Tehran is closer than ever to a bomb…